UK Rallying’s leading lights call for seeding rethink

Group National Editor

Leading figures in British rallying have called on UK motorsport’s rule makers to revisit the seeding rule due to falling entries, particularly on gravel events.

UK motorsport’s governing body, the Motor Sports Association, implemented a change to the order cars are allowed to run in 2015, following recommendations from the Scottish Government-instigated safety review after the fatal accidents on the 2013 Snowman Rally and the 2014 Jim Clark Rally.

The change forced rally organisers to run a road order based on the anticipated performance of cars and drivers, which has pushed two-wheel drive and historic entrants further back in the seeding. It means they often run on stages that have already been made rough and rutted and further risk damaging their cars.

While the performance-based order is used on MSA-permitted events, FIA-sanctioned rounds like the Circuit of Ireland in 2016 have been allowed to run different seeding. In that event, a round of the European Championship, competitors could pay for priority seeding to run at the front of the field.

That has left national rallying competitors and organisers confused as to why MSA events should run differently.

The seeding rule change has coincided with a dramatic drop in two-wheel-drive entries, especially in the BTRDA Rally Series, which previously had strong support at this level. Historic rallying has also been badly hit by the move.

Video: Why British Rallying needs an overhaul

Former world championship co-driver and event organiser Nicky Grist said: “The BTRDA has suffered because the class [1400cc cars] has diminished. There is a place for another 20 or 30 crews to come out if the stages were good, clean roads.

“There’s a good case we should reintroduce [being able to run two-wheel drives and historics further forward]. The sport needs it. We need as many competitors as we can get. We shouldn’t be too restrictive: we need to encourage more entries.”

Many national rallying insiders have suggested that the event bosses should be the ones to choose how to seed their running order, decided on their competitor base and the organisation of their particular rally.

Grist says things have to change to boost entries. Pic: Jakob Ebrey

Malcolm Wilson of M-Sport agrees that the BTRDA has been hit hard, but says putting two-wheel-drive cars at the front would not be beneficial for championships like the British Rally Championship.

“If we allowed two-wheel-drive cars to run first on the road at BRC level then they would get used to pretty perfect road conditions,” said Wilson. “Then, when they step up to the World Rally Championship, they would find the road in a completely different condition.

“As much as driving a car quickly is so important, learning how to get a car through a rough stage is a real skill as well. But I’m talking at the upper levels of rallying in Britain: I would imagine the case might be different further down the order.”

Smaller, two-wheel-drive cars have suffered badly. Pic:

Despite the support for a rethink on how events are seeded, especially given that FIA events are allowed to run a different procedure, the MSA appears unlikely to change for 2019.

An MSA spokesperson told Motorsport News: “The MSA’s position on running order has been subject to regular review ever since the ‘single field, fastest first’ seeding philosophy was reinforced nearly three years ago.

“It remains a topic of ongoing debate at the MSA through RallyFuture but, at this time, there are no plans to deviate from the current position.”

For the full investigation into the current state of national rallying, pick up this week’s Motorsport News, available at all good retailers and online on iOS or Google Play. Alternatively Subscribe here.

Recent news


Can WRC All Live kill traditional TV?

By David Evans

Rallying News

Al-Attiyah close to Toyota deal for WRC

Toyota Gazoo Racing will build a fourth Yaris WRC in time for Rally Argentina, as it nears an...

Racing News

New BTCC Alfa Romeo completes first test

The new British Touring Car Championship Alfa Romeo Giulietta broke cover for the first time...

Rallying News

WRC looking to add extra winter rally

The World Rally Championship could feature a second winter event in the future, according to...

Racing News

Eurotech to use same Honda engines as Dynamics

British Touring Car Championship title-winning team Eurotech will use the same Honda engines...

Rallying News

Ogier controversy prompts format change calls

World Rally Championship drivers and teams want changes to how national events share WRC bills...

Racing News

Points for overtaking in British F3 rule change

A point will be awarded to drivers in the BRDC British Formula 3 Championship for every position...


Why British F4 will survive without Carlin

By Stephen Lickorish

Rallying News

Breen 'gutted' to be moving aside for Loeb

Craig Breen admitted he is "gutted" that he will give way to Sebastien Loeb in the Citroen World...

Racing News

Chadwick returns to BRDC British F3

Jamie Chadwick will return to the BRDC British Formula 3 Championship this season with Douglas...

Racing News

Jelley rejoins BTCC, switches to BMW

Stephen Jelley will return to the British Touring Car Championship this season, but his Team...

Racing News

Barr switches to TCR Europe with Hyundai

Mini Challenge JCW Championship runner-up Reece Barr will graduate into the TCR Europe Series...

Rallying News

Neuville wins Rally Sweden, takes points lead

Thierry Neuville took his first World Rally Championship victory of the season with a dominant...

Rallying News

Neuville leads into final day of Rally Sweden

Hyundai World Rally Championship driver Thierry Neuville will carry a 22.7-second lead over...

Rallying News

Neuville extends Rally Sweden lead

Thierry Neuville added to his Rally Sweden lead on Saturday afternoon's loop as he and nearest...

Rallying News

Neuville hangs on to lead as Breen closes in

Thierry Neuville continues to lead Rally Sweden despite a spin on Saturday morning's stages,...

Rallying News

Neuville heads Hyundai 1-2-3 in Sweden

Thierry Neuville withstood attacks from Andreas Mikkelsen and Esapekka Lappi to maintain his...

Racing News

Motorbase parts ways with BTCC racer Jackson

British Touring Car Championship racer Mat Jackson has split from the Motorbase Performance...

Racing News

Monger 'not far away' from F3 deal

Billy Monger believes he is "not too far away" from securing a return to racing in the BRDC...

Rallying News

Neuville takes Sweden lead on Friday morning, Tanak fumes

Thierry Neuville leads Andreas Mikkelsen in a Hyundai World Rally team one-two after the first...

Rallying News

Tanak leads early Toyota one-two in Sweden

Toyota World Rally Championship driver Ott Tanak leads Rally Sweden ahead of the first full...

Rallying News

Ostberg pins Sweden chances on conditions

Citroen returnee Mads Ostberg hopes that winter conditions in Sweden this week can help him...

1 2 3 46

More national news, in-depth race reports and analysis. Subscribe to the Motorsport News paper today.

What’s On